Skip to content

Household’s bid to make use of floating helipad in remoted fiord as ‘vacation residence’ goes to court docket

A floating construction in an remoted fiord – full with a helicopter pad and a sizzling tub – is on the heart of a authorized dispute between a outstanding household and a regional council.

The construction has been a supply of disquiet in Tamatea/Dusky Sound, with critics claiming its house owners are positioning to make use of it as a “personal vacation residence”.

It belongs to The Alpine Group, which is majority owned by members of the outstanding Wallis household. It serves as a base for the corporate’s tourism enterprise, which advertises one-day excursions on the fiord for round $18,000 per constitution.

The corporate in 2015 purchased a dilapidated barge that had been used for storing fishing tools. Useful resource consent was granted in 2016 to exchange the barge, on the premise that it will be ‘like for like’. A number of native teams gave written consent on that foundation.

* Fiordland is gorgeous however do we all know how particular it’s?
* Distant Dusky Sound is New Zealand at its most interesting
* Protections thought-about for dolphins in Dusky Sound

However when the brand new construction was positioned in 2017, it was bigger than some had anticipated. It additionally had unreasonable additions: A storage shed, a hoist, two floating docks, laundry services, and a sizzling tub, an impartial commissioner concluded final 12 months.

After a compliance go to, Setting Southland instructed the corporate to use for retroactive consent for the additions. It did so in 2021.

As a part of that utility, the corporate made one other request: That relations and pals are allowed to make use of the construction for personal lodging for as much as 50 days per 12 months.

An image of the barge in Dusky Sound from a resource consent submission.


A picture of the barge in Dusky Sound from a useful resource consent submission.

At present, lodging is just allowed in extenuating circumstances, reminiscent of if climate prevents helicopters from flying.

The appliance was rejected by the impartial commissioner, Sharon McGarry, in August. In a scathing determination, she stated the unique utility for the construction contained “inaccuracies” relating to its measurement and use, and stated it was “controversial” that the construction as a complete was unconsented and subsequently illegal.

The corporate has appealed the choice to the Setting Court docket, the place subsequent month will probably be topic to court-assisted mediation.

‘Non-public vacation residence’

The construction has turn out to be a notable – and controversial – instance of growth in an space that has in any other case remained extremely pure.

Tamatea/Dusky Sound is among the many most inaccessible elements of New Zealand. It has no street entry or everlasting settlement. The construction is moored in Cascade Cove, which is without doubt one of the largest bays within the fiord and incorporates no different constructions.

Brook Sabin/Stuff

This wonderful secret spot in Fiordland can solely be reached by helicopter. If you wish to save up for one bucket record journey, that is it.

Business exercise has elevated within the fiord in latest instances, significantly for the reason that begin of the coronavirus pandemic. There are actually as much as 20 business operators, together with The Alpine Group, which largely supply chartered boat journeys although the fiord.

The brand new construction, specifically, has been a supply of pressure.

A number of teams opposed the latest consent utility, arguing the construction was already having a detrimental impression on the pure atmosphere and was taking over an excessive amount of area.

The Fiordland Marine Guardians, in its submission to the impartial commissioner, stated it had “severe considerations” in regards to the measurement of the construction, and accused the barge’s proprietor of making an attempt to show it right into a “personal vacation residence”.

The group had agreed to the unique consent for the construction on the premise it will be a “like for like” alternative. As an alternative, the construction was round 4 instances bulkier, the group estimated, and had turn out to be a “hub of exercise”.

The Division of Conservation (DOC) additionally opposed the appliance, describing it as “inappropriate”. If personal lodging was allowed, it will “have a precedent impact of permitting the coastal marine space of ​​Fiordland for use for personal residential exercise”, its submission stated.

The company’s Director-Basic, Penny Nelson, was “upset” that the applicant had “carried out vital additions to the barge construction with out acquiring a useful resource consent”, the submission stated.

The fiord’s kaitiaki, Oraka Aparima Rūnaka, additionally opposed the appliance: “We’re involved that the mauri, together with the pure character and visible amenity is negatively impacted by this proposal,” its submission stated.

The trade group for rock lobster fishing stated the proposal would have an “unacceptable adversarial impact on panorama, pure character and amenity values ​​of the realm”.

An aerial view of the barge in Dusky Sound from a promotional video.


An aerial view of the barge in Dusky Sound from a promotional video.

‘A protracted reference to Fiordland’

The bulk shareholders of The Alpine Group are the Wallis household, who’ve a “lengthy connection” with the realm.

“The household has continued to journey to the realm, staying on their very own vessels, and extra not too long ago staying on the barge,” it stated in its submission.

“They’ve an excessive amount of respect for the realm and wish to proceed to share this extraordinary a part of New Zealand with their family and friends, together with their very own youngsters, so that they have the chance to hold on this connection to the realm.”

Sir Tim Wallis pioneered the apply of capturing stay deer from helicopters and based the Warbirds Over Wanaka occasion.

The corporate additionally owns Minaret Station, a farm and luxurious lodge close to Wanaka. In 2011, the Nationwide Enterprise Evaluation estimated Wallis’ fortune at $70m.

In October, The Alpine Group was fined $325,000 for a helicopter crash that killed three folks: DOC staff Paul Hondelink and Scott Theobald, and pilot Nick Wallis, Sir Tim Wallis’ son.

One other of Wallis’ sons, Matt, had died in a separate helicopter crash three months earlier.

The original barge, before it was replaced with the current structure.

Setting Southland

The unique barge, earlier than it was changed with the present construction.

In its useful resource consent utility, the corporate stated it did not know on the time the barge didn’t meet the situations of the useful resource consent. Setting Southland workers had not raised considerations throughout a web site go to earlier than it was towed to Cascade Cove.

As a result of additions such because the floating docks, the storage shed, and the new tub weren’t a part of the structural design, they weren’t thought to breach the foundations.

The additions had little impression on the atmosphere past what was allowed, the corporate stated, and the construction itself was in a hid cove, that means it was not simply seen.

Its use for private lodging could be “opportunist in nature”, a doc submitted by the corporate stated. Non-public visits would solely occur sometimes, often for 2-3 days at a time, and require no modifications to the construction. The one change from the established order could be folks being there at evening.

Lodging wouldn’t be used for business purchasers – solely the household and pals of the corporate’s shareholders.

The arguments had been rejected by McGarry, who stated the construction and its related use, had been “leading to adversarial results on the atmosphere and are compromising these excellent values ​​that are of nationwide and worldwide significance and should be protected”.

The Alpine Group declined to remark, citing the continuing court docket motion.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *