Skip to content

How I Met Your Father’s Large Sophie & Barney Principle Formally Debunked

How I Met Your Father’s massive Sophie & Barney principle has been debunked by the showrunners, even after Barney’s cameo within the season 2 premiere.

Warning: This submit accommodates spoilers for the How I Met Your Father season 2 premiere.How I Met Your Father Showrunners Isaac Aptaker and Elizabeth Berger have debunked the favored fan principle that Barney Stinson is Sophie’s father. Whereas the principle thriller of the sequence is who the daddy of Sophie’s future youngster is, there may be additionally the thriller of who Sophie’s father is. How I Met Your Father season 1 that includes How I Met Your Mom characters together with Robin Scherbatsky and the Captain opened the door for extra acquainted characters to seem within the spinoff sequence, with their appearances having the potential to reply the thriller of Sophie’s parentage. This led to the speculation that notorious womanizer Barney Stinson may be Sophie’s father to her.


Whereas Barney does make an look within the How I Met Your Father season 2 premiere after Sophie unintentionally rear-ends his automobile, showrunners Aptaker and Berger verify in an interview with Leisure Weekly that he’s not Sophie’s father. They clarify that the speculation does not work due to the timeline established in each sequence. Sophie turns 30 in 2022, which means she was born in 1992. How I Met Your Mom revealed that Barney did not have intercourse for the primary time till 1999, which means he cannot be her father. Take a look at Aptaker and Berger’s rationalization under:

APTAKER: Yeah, we will debunk that, simply based mostly on the actual fact of the mathematics of it. He could be one thing like a sophomore in highschool. It is probably not the story that we’re attempting to inform.

BERGER: We by no means wish to dispel a principle as a result of we love an excellent fan principle however as a result of How I Met Your Mom followers are so diehard and so good at monitoring the timelines, and our followers are as properly now, we will safely say that that isn’t the case and he’s not the daddy.

RELATED: What Occurs Subsequent In How I Met Your Father (Primarily based On HIMYM’s System)

Different Methods Barney Might Match Into Sophie’s Story

How I Met Your Father Season 2 Episode 1 Barney Stinson Cameo Neil Patrick Harris

Although Barney is not Sophie’s father, he nonetheless has an essential position to play in How I Met Your Father. Within the interview with ewthe How I Met Your Father writers teased that they’ve concepts for all the unique How I Met Your Mom characters to return. Spinoff cameos for every character are usually not solely based mostly on the actors’ availability, but additionally on what makes probably the most sense for the place Sophie is at in her journey. Simply as Robin appeared within the How I Met Your Father season 1 finale to inform Sophie what she wanted to listen to at that particular level in her life, Sophie is operating into Barney as a result of he is the particular person she wants proper now.

The most important shift in Barney’s life passed off in 2020, a few years earlier than How I Met Your Father‘s timeline in 2022. The How I Met Your Mom sequence finale reveals that 2020 is the 12 months Barney’s daughter Ellie is born. The primary second Barney holds his daughter from him is a life-changing second the place he decides to lastly calm down and cease placing himself first as he realizes nothing and nobody is as essential as his daughter from him. Barney may give Sophie some much-needed perspective as he helps her concentrate on the folks she loves and turning into the most effective model of herself.

This can be a fascinating level within the timeline to discover Barney’s character. Barney’s How I Met Your Father cameo can present what life is like for him as a modified man simply a few years into fatherhood. As a womanizer and probably the most immature member of the core good friend group within the unique present, it’s ironic to suppose that he may now be a voice of purpose and knowledge for Sophie in How I Met Your Father. Just like Sophie, Barney didn’t know who his father was till a lot later in life. Barney isn’t Sophie’s dad, however he will be the daddy determine that she wants proper now.

NEXT: How I Met Your Father’s Largest Downside Might Assist The Spinoff

Supply: EW

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *